Introducing the Distinction between Subordinate Clauses and Independent Clauses
Identify the following word groups as PHRASE, SUBORDINATE CLAUSE, or INDEPENDENT CLAUSE.
For each item, click on one of the boxes and then click "Check." Feedback will appear in a pop-up window, and your cumulative score will appear here.
Clauses
Please study this lesson before attempting the exercise.
A clause can also be called a proposition or predication, since it proposes or predicates an idea rather than simply mentioning or referring to an idea. A clause predicates that "the baboon laughs." A phrase, on the other hand, merely mentions "the laughing baboon" or "the baboon's laughter." Both phrases and clauses, then, can relate the ideas of "baboon" and "laughter," but they do so in different ways. This is convenient for encoding and communicating complex ideas, such as "The baboon's laughter frightened the thief." This sentence expresses of two separate concepts: "The baboon laughed; the laughter frightened the thief," but it packages them compactly in the form of a single clause. The major idea in any sentence is always expressed in the form of a predication or clause, but phrases provide a means of embedding minor ideas inside major ones. The new lesson this exercise introduces is that human languages provide a second way for sentences to include minor ideas, and that is in the form of subordinate clauses. Thus, if our main idea was not that the thief was frightened by what he heard but that he dropped the loot when he heard the laugh, we could say, "When the baboon laughed, the thief dropped the diamonds down the drain."
A SUBORDINATE CLAUSE begins with a SUBORDINATE CONJUNCTION (since, because, although, while, as, if, unless, until, the fact that, etc.).
An INDEPENDENT CLAUSE does not begin with a subordinate conjunction.
a balding man in cowboy boots
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
is sitting by a small table in the hall
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
waiting to see his counselor
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
the picture of white-knuckled sobriety
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
he clenches a fist and holds it with his other hand
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
as if he would like to wring his hands
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
if he dared
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
he bows his head
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
then lifts it
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
disengages his hands
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
picks up his coffee cup
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
and brings it to his lips
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
pushing himself up
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
he hobbles
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
in his cowboy boots
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
from his seat
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
to the kitchen
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
across the hall
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
I hear the gush of the spigot
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
then back through the doorway
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
comes his dour, puzzled face
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
as he totters past me
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
he tugs a pack of cigarettes out of a sweater pocket
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
vanishing then into the hallway
Phrase
Subordinate Clause
Independent Clause
A sentence contains at least one independent clause. It may have more if they are joined by coordinate conjunctions (and, but, or, for, so, yet) or by a colon or semicolon. Joining them without one of these devices is considered an error, called a "comma fault" (if a comma alone is used) or a "fused sentence" (with no punctuation); the general name for such errors is a "run-on sentence."
Subordinate clauses and phrases are parts of sentences, not sentences themselves. If punctuated as sentences, they are judged errors and are called "sentence fragments."
Identify the correctly constructed sentences below.
The attic always smelled of coal dust as you mounted the bare wooden steps to the landing.
Correct
Incorrect
As you mounted the bare wooden steps to the landing, the temperature in summer would rise five degrees.
Correct
Incorrect
The attic always smelled of coal dust as you mounted the bare wooden steps to the landing, the temperature in summer would rise five degrees.
Correct
Incorrect
As you mounted the bare wooden steps to the landing, the temperature in summer would rise five degrees and then another five as you reached the top.
Correct
Incorrect
As you mounted the bare wooden steps to the landing, the temperature in summer would rise five degrees and then another five as you reached the top, the light came from three sides.
Correct
Incorrect
As you reached the top, the light came from three sides.
Correct
Incorrect
The light came from three sides, but on one side the roof sloped down to the floor.